10 Must-Try Restaurants in Nassau Bahamas for a Memorable Island Meal

Most people think of Nassau as turquoise blue water, white sand beaches, and luxury resorts. Yet there is something else that really defines the Bahamian experience: the food. From fresh seafood served seaside to gourmet European dishes with a Bahamian twist, Nassau has you covered—especially with the incredible restaurants at Baha Mar Resort and beyond.

If you’re staying at Baha Mar Resort, you’re right in the heart of some of the island’s best dining options. But step out beyond the resort gates, and there are even more amazing places to discover, from hidden-away bistros to open-air grills with views of the Caribbean. These 10 dining spots will ensure your trip is unforgettable. Let us explore.

Top Ten Restaurants at Baha Mar Resort for A Great Dining Experience

Here are the top restaurants 

1. Oh Andros

Set in Nassau’s colourful fish fry district, Oh Andros is beloved for its bold Bahamian seafood and huge portions. It’s casual, it’s buzzing, and it serves some of the crispiest snapper and grilled shrimp on the island.

If you’re venturing beyond Baha Mar, arrange a quick ride using Baha Mar car services to get there comfortably. It’s the kind of place where one dish feeds two, and the flavor keeps you coming back.

2. Banana Bay

Tucked on Fortune Beach, Banana Bay blends laid-back island charm with delicious Caribbean classics. Their conch fritters come perfectly seasoned, and the chicken wings with fries are a comfort food favourite. But the star of the show? Their warm, house-made banana bread.

You can enjoy the breeze and ocean views while sipping a cool drink. If you’re heading there from Nassau, it’s worth booking a luxury car service near Baha Mar for the full island experience.

3. Pier One 

Pier One is a fun surprise offering sushi rolls, seafood platters, and pasta with a Caribbean-Asian twist. Located near Hawksbill Creek, it offers a front-row seat to the ocean, and if you’re lucky, you might spot sharks circling below.

This spot pairs a unique menu with unbeatable views. It’s ideal for a more adventurous palate and makes a great dinner stop after a day of sightseeing.

4. Cocoplum Bistro & Bar 

For something elegant yet relaxed, head to Cocoplum Bistro & Bar, located between Old Fort Bay and Lyford Cay. French Chef Cathelin’s menu is creative and island-inspired, think watermelon salad, coconut chickpea curry, grilled octopus, and lamb that melts in your mouth.

Set in a lush garden setting, it’s a favourite for romantic dinners. Use Baha Mar transportation for a smooth trip out west. It’s a hidden gem that’s well worth the short drive.

5. Santanna’s Bar and Grill 

If you’re exploring the Exumas, Santanna’s Bar and Grill is your go-to for an authentic Bahamian meal. This no-frills eatery is big on flavour. Cracked conch, deep-fried lobster, and grilled snapper are just the beginning.

With open views of the turquoise sea and the occasional shark gliding by, the setting is unbeatable. Meals are made fresh, so be ready to sip a rum cocktail while you wait.

6. Kyma Seafood Grill Windsor Field Road

Modern, upbeat, and always buzzing, Kyma Seafood Grill mixes Greek and Latin flavours with Bahamian warmth. The menu is affordable and features crowd-pleasing gyros, seafood, zucchini tempura, and even weekend brunch.

This is a great casual spot not far from Baha Mar. If you’re staying at the resort, use Baha Mar car services to reach your destination easily.

7. Queen Conch 

Colourful and relaxed, Queen Conch sits right on the water and serves, what else, some of the best conch in town. Whether it’s in salad, chowder, or fritters, it’s all delicious, especially with a splash of their spicy house-made sauce.

The menu also features grouper fingers, stone crab, and tropical shrimp dishes. It’s the perfect place to unwind with a fruity Goombay Smash and ocean breeze in your hair. This is one of the finest places to enjoy authentic Bahamian conch near the Baha Mar Resort.

8. Graycliff Restaurant 

For a more refined experience, Graycliff Restaurant inside the historic Graycliff Hotel offers luxury dining at its best. From Filet Mignon to Dover Sole, every dish is thoughtfully plated and beautifully served.

The restaurant is also home to one of the largest wine cellars in the Caribbean. Make sure you dress the part. This is a fine-dining venue with a formal dress code. A luxury car service from Baha Mar makes the perfect arrival for such a memorable evening.

9. 1648 

1648 brings elegance and flavour together in the best way. Located on Eleuthera, it offers sunset views and island-inspired dishes with a modern twist. Their lobster is a showstopper, whether you get it with pasta or as the main course.

Time your dinner with sunset, grab a seat on the deck, and you’ll see why this spot is a favourite for both locals and travellers.

10. Café Matisse

Located in the heart of the capital, Café Matisse has long been a go-to for Italian-inspired dining with a Caribbean soul. The ambience is elegant but not stuffy, and the dishes like Burrata, Risotto alla Zucca, and Triangoli al Vitello are packed with personality.

It’s a great choice for a romantic night out or a relaxing dinner after shopping in town. If you’re staying at Baha Mar, book a ride through Baha Mar transportation services and enjoy the short drive downtown in comfort.

Final Thoughts

Dining in Nassau is about more than just the food; it’s about the views, the company, and the moments you’ll remember long after the meal. Whether you’re dining in luxury at the restaurants at Baha Mar Resort or venturing out to discover local favourites, you’re in for a treat.

And don’t forget, getting around the island is part of the experience. Book reliable Baha Mar car services from Simon’s Transports to explore the culinary scene in comfort and style. From five-star restaurants to beachside grills, Nassau’s food scene is bursting with flavor, just waiting for you to dive in.

Frequently Asked Questions